Every probate attorney has been there — waiting on an appraisal while the 90-day clock ticks and heirs get restless.
After handling over 120 estate appraisals across Kentucky, I’ve seen how one late or unclear report can derail an otherwise clean case.
You’ve filed the petition. The hearing is scheduled. Everything’s on track — until the appraisal disappears into a black hole for three weeks, and suddenly you’re the one fielding angry calls from beneficiaries who think you’re stalling.
This isn’t about real estate values. It’s about control, speed, and your client’s confidence in you.
When the appraisal process breaks down, your reputation takes the hit — not the appraiser’s.
The Real Problem: Appraisals That Create More Work
Most appraisers treat probate like any other assignment.
They don’t understand that your timeline isn’t a suggestion — it’s a court order with consequences.
Here’s what that looks like in practice:
- Missed deadlines that trigger show-cause orders or force continuances
- Radio silence that makes you look unresponsive when heirs call asking for updates
- Vague reports that spark disputes instead of settling them
- Inexperienced appraisers who need hand-holding, turning you into a project manager instead of an attorney
And when that happens, it’s not just a delay — it’s a credibility hit.
“If an appraiser disappears for a week, it’s the attorney’s reputation that takes the hit.”
You didn’t go to law school to babysit vendors. Yet here you are, chasing down someone who should be making your job easier.
The Fallout: When Client Trust Erodes
When an appraisal is late or unclear, heirs don’t call the appraiser — they call you.
Suddenly you’re managing family dynamics, mediating disputes over comparable sales, and burning billable hours explaining why a property is worth X instead of Y.
Every conflict costs you:
- Time you could spend on actual legal work
- Emotional energy managing irrational family drama
- Reputation as heirs wonder why this is taking so long
And the worst part? None of this is your fault — but it’s absolutely your problem.
The truth is, attorneys don’t want another appraisal. They want a fast, defensible, drama-free process that lets them stay in control.
What the Best Probate Attorneys Look For
After working with hundreds of estate cases, I’ve noticed the top-performing attorneys all use the same criteria when choosing appraisal partners:
1. Speed with substance
Fast turnaround that doesn’t sacrifice accuracy. Court deadlines matter, and a 3–5-day delivery window keeps cases moving while staying defensible.
2. Proactive communication
Updates before you have to ask. When you can tell heirs “the appraiser will be there Tuesday” instead of “I’m still waiting to hear back,” you control the narrative.
3. Court-ready clarity
Reports written so heirs understand them, judges approve them, and the IRS accepts them. Technical accuracy matters, but so does plain-English explanation that prevents disputes before they start.
4. Deep comparable analysis
20–30 sales analyzed, not three. When someone challenges the value (and someone always does), you need depth that holds up under scrutiny.
5. Probate-specific formatting
Reports structured for estate administration from day one — not generic lender templates you have to translate for court use.
“The right appraisal partner makes you look organized, professional, and in control — exactly the way your clients expect to see you.”
Three Questions to Ask Before Hiring Any Estate Appraiser
Before you bring an appraiser onto your next case, ask these three questions.
Their answers will tell you everything.
1. “What’s your average turnaround time for probate appraisals — and what causes delays?”
- Good answer: A specific timeline (3–7 days) with an honest discussion of what could slow things down (access issues, complex properties).
- Red flag: Vague promises or “it depends.”
2. “How many comparable sales do you typically analyze, and how do you explain valuation to heirs?”
- Good answer: 20+ comps with a clear explanation method. They should talk about plain-English summaries, not just technical reports.
- Red flag: “Whatever USPAP requires” or “3–5 comps.”
3. “How do you communicate updates to attorneys during the process?”
- Good answer: Proactive milestone updates via your preferred method. They should ask how you want to be updated.
- Red flag: “Call me if you need anything.” That makes you the project manager.
The best appraisers understand they’re not just valuing property. They’re protecting your timeline and your reputation.
The Bottom Line
You can’t control family dynamics. You can’t control court calendars.
But you can control who you trust with the appraisal process.
The goal isn’t just getting a number on a page. It’s protecting your timeline, your credibility, and your ability to focus on actual legal work instead of vendor management.
When the appraisal is handled right, heirs agree, judges approve, and you get back to practicing law — not playing referee.
Next Move:
Before your next estate case, run through those three questions with your appraiser.
Their answers will tell you instantly whether you’re dealing with a partner or a liability.
If this hit home, I’m happy to send over our Attorney Checklist for Vetting Estate Appraisers — the exact questions that separate pros from problems. Or, if you prefer a quick conversation, we can jump on a short call and I’ll walk you through how to use it. Either way, I hope this gave you something useful for your next estate case.
Conrad Meertins, Jr. is a certified residential appraiser specializing in probate and estate valuations. With over 867 estate appraisals completed and zero valuation disputes, he works exclusively with attorneys and personal representatives who need court-ready reports on compressed timelines.